Fan Classifications
June 16th, 2009 Posted by Esther Inglis-ArkellWhen you ask a certain type of person what kind of comics they like; well, first they’ll correct you. They will say ‘graphic novels.’ And then they will tell you that they don’t have one specific interest, they just like high-quality graphic novels.
While I can admire a search for the best quality products of a medium that you like, I’ve always felt a certain contemptuous pity for those people. Really? Just ‘high-quality’? Just ‘good’? Just ‘insightful’? These people are either liars, or are the stunted, gnarled, embittered kind of jerks who will tell you that they only listen to classical music and NPR. Sure, their taste is unquestionable and their likes and dislikes as pure as the driven snow, but – really? They have no guilty pleasures? No specific areas of interest? No morbid curiosity? No nostalgic favorites or fannish loves or goofy objects of affection? It just seems so flavorless and bland.
And I can say this because I without a doubt know that those people, when I tell them I like the Batsquad and the Arrows and have an irrational prejudice against Marvel, pity me just as much.
As well they might. I’m a character-based-fan. That? Is like attending a Rolling Stones concert, making it backstage, and spending the whole time talking about your favorite member of the Monkees.
There are many humiliations to being a character-based-fan. Start out with the fact that, prestige-wise, you are the lowest rung of the ladder (and considering you’re already into comics, that’s a really low ladder to begin with). Add to that that artist-based-fans can flit to one book or another, ignoring all plot and dialogue and rhapsodizing about a page layout, and writer-based-fans can camp out for a story-arc or two before moving on. A character-based fan is pretty much stuck in a book forever. We’re like those frogs who get put in cold water, and then don’t jump out when it’s heated up, boiling ourselves to death. But at least the frogs go quietly. Character-based-fans are the ones at Cons, arguing with a panel of uncomfortable comics-professionals about how our character would never do that, while the audience hisses at us.
We’re the idiots who get into ‘who would win in a fight’ arguments and talk about the logistics of what Batman can carry around in his utility belt, and complain about how terrible a comic is while they’re buying it.
Still better than yakking about the artistic merits of Lost Girls, though.